Select Page

The Progspace Awards 2022

Without Waves – Comedian

Without Waves – Comedian

Without Waves - Comedian

  • Rating: 7/10
  • Release Date: 18 March, 2022
  • Label: Prosthetic Records
  • Musicians:
    Zac Lombardi - guitars
    Anthony Cwan - guitars & vocals
    John Picillo - bass & vocals
    Gary Naples - drums
  • Favorite songs:
    Do What Scares You, .algorithm, Day 15
  • For Fans of:
    The Dillinger Escape Plan, Meshuggah, Tool

Every now and then an album comes along that has the potential to become the next big thing, but it just doesn’t reach the true sweet spot. A classic case of close, but no cigar. “Comedian” by Chicago-based progressive metal outfit Without Waves is such an effort…

On ‘Good Grief’ the band goes full-on Strapping Young Lad meets The Dillinger Escape Plan. Constantly shifting polyrhythms, jackhammer type riffs and a vocalist who does his utmost to channel his inner Devy, Mike Patton and Greg Puciato. ‘Animal Kingdom’ and ‘.algorithm’ continue in that vicious vein, both showing the band’s technical prowess, a knack for intelligent songwriting and utter musical savagery. ‘Set & Setting’ is another showstopper with some cleverly placed hooks and melodic vocal lines, giving the listener a short breather.

Without Waves – Good Grief

The mood and pace of “Comedian” change drastically with ‘Sleep Deep’. It’s a mid-paced track with some slight doomy undertones, say a kind of less manic and theatrical ‘Love?’ by the aforementioned Strapping Young Lad. ‘Do What Scares You’ sees Without Waves return to the manic first quarter of the album. ‘Day 15’, ‘Worlds Apart’ and ‘Seven’ shows a more melodic and experimental side of Without Waves, with extensive forays into the alternative rock, progressive rock and post-rock realm. This should appeal to Intronaut, Tool and Isis fans.

“Comedian” shows two distinct sides of this band. There’s the vicious cut-throat attack of the first four tracks on one side and the more brooding and atmospheric nature of the album’s second half. It makes for a very interesting and adventurous listening experience, yet these two distinct elements never seem to come together in a harmonious way. Therefore, “Comedian” has a somewhat incoherent and unbalanced feel.

Also, there’s nothing wrong with paying tribute to one’s influences and musical heroes. However, The Meshuggah, The Dillinger Escape Plan and Tool worship on “Comedian” gets a little bit under my skin here and there. If the band can address the aforementioned oversights next time around, we might have the next Gojira or Mastodon on our hands.

Without Waves – Seven

Everyone’s a comedian as the saying goes. However, “Comedian” by Without Waves is no laughing matter. It’s pugnacious and savage, yet undeniably clever and sophisticated. If you look for something different and you don’t mind some blatant hero worship, this is the album to go for.


  1. Good Grief
  2. Animal Kingdom
  3. .algorithm 
  4. Set & Setting
  5. Sleep Deep
  6. Do What Scares You
  7. Sleight In Shadows
  8. Day 15
  9. Worlds Apart
  10. Seven

About the Author


Raymond is a fourty something Dutch male, very much into travelling, foreign languages and cultures, history, philosophy, reading, architecture, art and literature. Lately dabbling somewhat with writing and urban photography. Has a healthy appreciation for King Crimson, Ulver, Trent Reznor/Nine Inch Nails, Frank Zappa, Miles Davis, Cynic, Charles Mingus, Tool, Deftones, Omar Rodríguez-López/The Mars Volta, Isis, Anathema, The Gathering, Mike Patton/Faith No More, Meshuggah, Snarky Puppy, Nevermore, Chelsea Wolfe, The Comet Is Coming, Bach, Beethoven, Chopin, The Cinematic Orchestra and much more.

What’s Hot?! – Our latest Weekly Playlist

Releases of the Week – Spotify Playlist

A lot of news happen on Facebook: FOLLOW US!

Progtalks by The Progspace

Listen to our newest episode right here!

Progtalks by the Progspace
Or tune in on your favorite podcast app!

About us

ico-2 We’re a group of Prog-lovers who started a journey to share with you our thoughts about albums, concerts, tours and festivals, the photo galleries of the Prog concerts we visit, as well interviews with upcoming or established musicians or prog-related people. Follow our Facebook page for frequent updates and news around the Progniverse.

Read more…